All of us at St. Paul’s Day School are dedicated to providing exciting and enriching classrooms where learning is fun and children are known and valued. Our faculty of nearly 30 teachers are professionals with tender hearts who strive to create positive learning experiences for children. Our head teachers all have a Bachelor’s or Master’s degree with some form of Certification in Early Childhood/Elementary Education in New Jersey. Some of our assistant teachers are also New Jersey Certified teachers while others have their CDA (Child Development Associate), Associate or Bachelor’s Degrees. All of our staff continues to educate themselves in early childhood education each year in professional workshops to keep up to date with the latest pedagogy.
All staff is regularly trained in CPR, First Aid and in the use of the Automated External Defibrillator (AED) for both children and adults.

Staff Member | Role(s) | ||
![]() |
Amanda Reardon | Director | areardon@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Galadriel Hasbrouck | Assistant Director | ghasbrouck@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Betsy Belden | Kindergarten Head Teacher | bbelden@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Carol Fahrenthold | Kindergarten Teacher | cfahrenthold@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Rachel Manzo | Kindergarten Teacher | rmanzo@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Stephen Papa | Kindergarten Assistant Teacher | spapa@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Sue Coccaro | Kindergarten Assistant Teacher | scoccaro@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Maggi Jairdullo | Kindergarten Assistant Teacher | mjairdullo@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Lisa Pasternak | Kindergarten Assistant Teacher | lpasternak@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Holly Stefanik | Kindergarten Student Teacher | hstefanik@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Barbara McMahon | Junior Kindergarten Teacher | bmcmahon@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Amy Cabral | Junior Kindergarten Assistant Teacher | acabral@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Lisa Mola | Fabulous Fours Head Teacher | lmola@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Colleen Ceraso | Fabulous Fours Teacher | cceraso@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Karen Lack | Fabulous Fours Teacher | klack@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Lynn Pritti | Fabulous Fours Teacher | lpritti@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Kelly Costelloe | Fabulous Fours Assistant Teacher | kcostelloe@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Jane O’Donnell | Threes Adventures Head Teacher | jodonnell@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Marlene Kalaigian | Threes Adventures Teacher | mkalaigian@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Sue Koket | Threes Adventures Teacher | skoket@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Carolyn Melillo | Two-and-a-Halfs & Threes Adventures Teacher | cmelillo@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Laura Higginbotham | Threes Adventures Assistant Teacher | lhigginbotham@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Susan Jones | Threes Adventures Assistant Teacher | sjones@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Barbara Yuhas | Threes Adventures Assistant Teacher | byuhas@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Regina Colasanti | Threes Adventures & Enrichment Assistant Teacher | rcolasanti@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Mary Ann Hill | Two-and-a-Halfs Teacher | mahill@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Liz Pinheiro | Time for Twos Teacher & Enrichment Assistant | lpinheiro@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Annie Okas | Enrichment Teacher | aokas@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Trish Mosco | Floater | tmosco@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Lynn Cacici | After Care Teacher | lcacici@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Bina Desai | After Care Teacher | bdesai@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Elsa Meiner | After Care Teacher | emeiner@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Chrissy Mosco | Permanent Substitute | cmosco@stpaulsday.org |
![]() |
Jen Offerman | Substitute | |
![]() |
Jessica Fineburg | Substitute |